9.5 TOTAL SCORE

pickering 68 series: 68-1-a-12 relay

Electronic components
Build quality 10
Implemented technology 10
Ease-of-use 10
Price 8
PROS
  • Excellent performance
  • Small footprint, unique case design
  • Quiet operation
CONS
  • Some of the priciest relays out there
Bottomline

Pickering's 67 and 68 series of relays are quite good, offering impressive specs in a small, PCB-mounted format. Much of this isn't possible with conventional tech, forcing Pickering to create unique solutions. These bespoke parts drive the costs per unit up, but in mission-critical machinery it's a warranted expense.

Introduction

Pickering 68 series of reed relays have an impressive data-sheet. Distinguished by their flying lead design and their impressive 50 W power rating (but not quite as impressive as the company’s own 67 series’ 200 W one).

High switching voltages of up to 7.5 kV and even higher standoff ones of up to 10 kV further complement the impressive specs list which can be found on the manufacturer’s website.

Benchmarks

We’re interested in testing the real-world performance of our sample series 68 relay. We began this by checking the internal contacts’ resistance. This figure was reported as 0.011 ohms by our Fluke 289 when testing a factory-fresh relay. Coil resistance is a big factor in determining end-of-life for a relay. Pickering themselves consider anything above 1 ohm to be faulty. Each little spark during a switch cycle causes minuscule amounts of corrosion to form on the read contacts, inevitably increasing the contact resistance by a little. We’re not concerned about longevity here, however, as the measured figure is quite good – and is around ten times better than the manufacturer specified worst-case value.

Our relay came with a 12 V coil, which according to the data-sheet must operate at 9 volts and must release at a minimum of 1.2 volts. In our tests, we got 6.55 V as the lowest voltage to initiate a contact which would keep open until a drop of below 3.8 V. This yet again significantly outperforms the specifications set forth by the manufacturer.

An always interesting metric is the bounce time of a relay. While the initial contact usually happens instantaneously after power is applied to the coil, the reeds physically “bounce” again each other, sparking and delaying the true switching time by a number of microseconds. This phase of the switching cycle is the most damaging one due to the series of rapid microsecond-long electrical discharges.

Pickering 68-series relay bounce time during a cold switch, oscilloscope zoom-out view

Bounce time during cold switching (all graphs show the PSU voltage in purple and relay output in yellow)

Yet another bounce time oscilloscope view, slightly zoomed in

Zoomed in view of the bounce

Deatil shot of the cold-switch bounce

Cold bounce, detail shot with vertical scale set to 50 microseconds per division

Our oscilloscope screenshots demonstrate this bounce in action, both during cold switching and during the control of a modest load (9V/0.2A). Current flow through the contacts exacerbates bounce, making it noticeably longer, but still giving results which are covered by the spec-sheet.

Pickering 68 series bounce under load, oscilloscope view

Bounce time under load

Pickering 68 series bounce under load, oscilloscope view, detail

Bounce time under load, zoomed on detail

Release times were also perfectly in-spec, as seen by the photos below. Keep our measured must-operate and must-release values in mind when reading all oscilloscope charts for most precise data interpretation.

Relay release curve, oscilloscope view

Release time graph

Relay release, detail

Relay release, zoomed on detail

While we didn’t test breakdown voltages and other high-voltage specs, we have no reason to believe they aren’t correct. In our tests, the switch was also exceptionally quiet, making almost no noise when engaging and a faintly audible (mostly tactile, actually) click. We’d also like to note the brilliant casing design which allows for a very high packing density on a breadboard or PCB. Impressive for such high-voltage components.

Conclusion

Overall, the Series 68 relays are reliable, powerful and generously designed. In our independent tests, we were able to verify that all of the real-world performance metrics fully meet and exceed the manufacturer’s claims. We also commend the effort in providing high-quality and freely available documentation. A single Series 67/68 relay will set you back approximately $50, but different models can vary slightly in price. This might seem pricey for a relay, but in applications where safety is at stake (and we’d argue all high-voltage applications fit the bill), it’s a worthwhile investment.


More information: Pickering Series 67 / 68

Dušan Dakić